Commission for a Renewed Lutheran Church
Annotated Bibliography

Contents
Commission for a Renewed Lutheran Church
on ELCA website
ELCA.org/CRLC

The following is curated for your consideration.

Governing Documents

High Level Documents

  • Constitution, Bylaws, and Continuing Resolutions of the ELCA (2022) — includes the governing documents for the Churchwide Expression, the Constitution for Synods (with required provisions), and the Model Constitution for Congregations of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. N.B., both the Constitution for Synods and the Model Constitution for Congregations contain both required provisions (marked with a † for synods and an * for congregations) and non-required provisions. A given synod's constitution or congregation's constitution may vary.

Policy Documents

Those governing instruments that are subordinate to the Constitution, Bylaws, and Continuing Resolutions. Frequently, policy documents are adopted by the Church Council under authorization to do so in the Constitution, Bylaws, and Continuing Resolutions.

  • Manual of Policies and Procedures for Management of the Rosters of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (2022) — a.k.a. "Roster Manual." This is a policy document and is written as such. Everything one might want to know about the rosters of ministry in the ELCA. Includes items related to entry onto the rosters (ordination), limitations on types of calls, regular calls vs. calls to specialized ministry, on-leave from call, retirement, disability, ecumenical service, retirement, and removal from the roster. Fleshes out in detail those things that are named in the Constitution, Bylaws, and Continuing Resolutions.
  • Candidacy Manual (2019) — This is a policy document and is written as such. Everything one might want to know about the candidacy process for ministers of Word & Sacrament and Ministers of Word & service. This document covers all those preparing for the ministry and ultimately their examination and approval for ordination.

Churchwide Assembly Actions

  • "Report of the Memorials Committee." 2022 Pre-assembly Report, Section I. Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. (see p.48) — Provides those memorials related to the work of this Commission, including the memorials submitted by synods, the background material from the Memorials Committee, and the recommendation of the Memorials Committee.
  • "Legislative Update, Tuesday, August 9, 2022." Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. (see p.4) — Final form of the recommendation of the Memorials Committee (a substitution by the chairs), a floor amendment, and adoption of amended form. This does not include full floor debate. It is a summary of actions.
  • "Reports and Records: Assembly Minutes." 2022 Churchwide Assembly 2022. Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. (see pp. 78-87) —Full report and floor debate on matters related to the authorization of this Commission.

Essays & Articles

  • Riegel, Matthew Lynn. "Framing the Question (Bishop's Report, Part 2)." Proceedings of the Thirty-Third Annual Assembly of the West Virginia – Western Maryland Synod, Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, 16 October 2019. —An essay exploring whether a particular synod should exist in terms of the historic rationale for synodical polity in America.
  • Riegel, Matthew Lynn. "The Prince-Bishop in Augustana XXVIII." Paper for the Academy of Bishops, 6 January 2023. — An exegesis of the critical article in the Augsburg Confession (1530) relating to ecclesiastical office and civil office when the two offices are occupied by the same person. As an exegetical exercise, this paper situations Melanchthon's arguments within the context of political theory at the time of the Reformation.
  • Schmucker, B.M. "The Organization of the Congregation in the Early Lutheran Churches in America," Lutheran Church Review (July 1887). —An historic historical study of the origins and development of congregational polity among Lutheran churches in America. Divorced from the state-church of Europe, American Lutherans had to largely fend for themselves. A limitation of this study is its terminus ad quem of 1887. Still, it offers insight into a process that will be repeated.

Monographs

  • Almen, Lowell G. One Great Cloud of Witnesses! You and Your Congregation in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 2001. — A comprehensive introduction to the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, as it existed from up to 2000. Explores origins and the works of the churchwide expression, synods, congregations, various ministries, and the people.
  • Fortenbaugh, Robert. The Development of the Synodical Polity of the Lutheran Church in America, to 1829. Ph.D. dissertation University of Pennsylvania, 1926. —The seminal and definitive work that dovetails nicely with Beale Melanchthon Schmucker's work on the development of congregational polity. Not having the organized state-church in the Americas (with the exception of the New Sweden Colony), American Lutherans realized that congregations would benefit from cooperation. This work traces those early efforts to organize synodical polity, ultimately leading to the development of suprasynodical polity.
  • The New Church Debate: Issues Facing American Lutheranism. Edited and with introduction by Carl E. Braaten. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1983. — A collection of papers given at a conference of theologians held in the early days of the work of the Commission for a New Lutheran Church. A variety of topics are addressed with a high degree of honesty about the challenges of bringing together three churches to form on in the context of the late twentieth century.
  • Olson, Kathryn Marie. "Toward Uniting a Fellowship Divided: A Dramatistic Analysis of the Constitution-writing Process of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America." Ph.D. dissertation Northwestern University, 1987. — A study in rhetoric in which the language and arguments employed by the members of the Commission for a New Lutheran Church are examined in light of the most hotly contested issues before the Commission. Especially useful in understanding the struggles encountered in forming the new church and revealing in terms of the ongoing difficulties of being one church. Unfortunately, this work is not available in a public domain source. It can be secured through inter-library loan or through Proquest (a dissertation service). It may be possible to get permission for reproduction.
  • Trexler, Edgar. Anatomy of a Merger: People, Dynamics, and Decisions that Shaped the ELCA. Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1991. —Not as scholarly as Olson and certainly lacking the particular interest in rhetoric. A good study of the merger nonetheless. Fairly well-balanced.

Reports

  • Report & Recommendations of the Commission for a New Lutheran Church, 29 August 1986. — A digital version is not online but could probably be produced by asking the ELCA Archives for it. Should be readily available in any synod office among its collection of past proceedings. Culmination of the work of the Commission for a New Lutheran Church.
  • "Report of the 'Living into the Future Together: Renewing the Ecology of the ELCA' Task Force." With accompanying appendices. In 2011 Pre-Assembly Report, 2011. — Facing significant institutional challenges, the Living into the Future Together Task Force asked how we might continue as the ELCA in the midst of those challenges.

Other resources may be added over time, so check back. Additionally, if you would like to suggest a resource, contact +Riegel.


 



West Virginia-Western Maryland Synod
℅ St. Paul Lutheran Church
309 Baldwin Street, Morgantown, WV 26505
304-363-4030  +  Porter@WV-WMD.org